Current:Home > News'Rich White Men' reinforces the argument that inequality harms us all-InfoLens
'Rich White Men' reinforces the argument that inequality harms us all
View Date:2024-12-23 15:53:30
Drawing from a collection of captivating anecdotes and supported by extensive data, Garrett Neiman's Rich White Men: What It Takes to Uproot the Old Boys' Club and Transform America makes a compelling argument that inequality harms us all.
People in marginalized communities must reckon with having unequal access to the opportunities that make success nearly a foregone conclusion for those positioned on the highest rungs of the socioeconomic ladder. But, Neiman argues, social and economic inequities prevent even the rich white men at the top of the power structure from being able to experience their full humanity.
This is hardly a new concept; just two years ago Heather McGhee's brilliant book, The Sum of Us: What Racism Costs Everyone and How We Can Prosper Together, was longlisted for the National Book Award for its exploration of the same premise, albeit one focused more closely on race.
Neiman succeeds in making distinct contributions to this conversation, though. First, as a rich white man himself, he has an insider's access to that population. This enables him to participate in frank conversations that demonstrate how even "the liberal and philanthropic elite" regularly operate from a foundation of problematic biases and can be especially attached to the myth of meritocracy. While "equal opportunity and meritocracy are alluring, aspirational ideas," he argues they can only be unattainable ideals without significant structural changes that redirect our path towards equity.
Importantly, Neiman doesn't shy away from self-indictment, regularly pointing out where he has fallen short — and where he continues to struggle — as he strives to maintain an orientation towards justice. He draws from his own experience with humility and critical self-reflection without falling into the trap of virtue signaling, at one point noting that "if [his] spouse had not gone to great lengths to get [his] attention, this chapter [on male advantage] wouldn't even be in the book."
Perhaps most notably, Neiman employs a particularly effective metaphor, that of "compounding unearned advantage" to demonstrate how racial and gender advantages amass at an exponential rate, creating more profound inequities over time. This analogy builds on the Racial Equity Institute's framework of "unearned advantage," which "carries less baggage and is less loaded than 'privilege.'" (Neiman helpfully notes that this shift is less about making "those who benefit from unearned advantage comfortable but to find a starting point for a constructive conversation in which everyone feels invested in addressing inequality.") The concept feels a bit like the inverse of intersectionality, the term coined by UCLA law professor Kimberlé Crenshaw and "which she describes as 'a metaphor for understanding the ways that multiple forms of inequality or disadvantage sometimes compound themselves.'"
Neiman documents the cost of compounding unearned interest to marginalized communities, referencing study upon study that underscores the advantages bestowed upon rich white men. The broad strokes, if not the exact statistics, of some of this data will be familiar to those who follow socioeconomic trends in the U.S. Expanding income and wealth divides in this country mean that the top 1 percent now "hold 32 percent of the wealth — about $40 trillion" in addition to nearly 20 percent of income, Neiman cites. The adage of the rich getting richer while the poor experience the opposite is borne out by the reality that "two-thirds of families in poverty remain in poverty a decade later, while most high-income families stay in the top strata." Still, thanks to the breadth of data Neiman presents, even the well-informed will likely encounter more than a few statistical surprises.
I only count myself among the moderately well-informed, but I was still stunned to discover that the "glass cliff" — the dynamic of people of color being elevated to positions of power when institutions are at their least stable — had been studied at all, let alone by multiple universities. Less shocking were the findings themselves: Utah State University researchers reviewing a 15-year span at Fortune 500 companies "found that white women and people of color were more likely than white men to be promoted to CEO at weakly performing firms."
Though the data in Rich White Men might be despairing, Neiman is anything but. In the book's first part, "How the Old Boys Club Reproduces Itself," he builds an unassailable argument for creating a future in which we all can thrive. The second part, "Becoming Equitable," explores concrete — and ambitious — strategies for doing so. They include abolishing poverty, creating a culture of repair, and restoring connection. The chapters in both sections of the book open with epigraphs identifying a myth ("If America addresses economic injustice, racial justice will be solved" and the truth it obscures ("Controlling for wealth, whiteness offers compounding unearned advantages.") To create an equitable society, it is imperative that rich white men reject those myths. It is imperative that we all do. And in doing so, Neiman writes, "we can build a healthy society where everyone feels valued, supported, and able to be their true selves."
Anyone interested in that ultimate goal would benefit from reading this book.
Ericka Taylor is the popular education manager for Take on Wall Street and a freelance writer. Her work has appeared in Bloom, The Millions, Willow Springs and Yes! Magazine.
veryGood! (57)
Related
- Outgoing North Carolina governor grants 2 pardons, 6 commutations
- Judge to fine a Massachusetts teachers union an extra $50,000 a day if 6-day strike continues
- Ingenuity, NASA's little Mars helicopter, ends historic mission after 72 flights
- 3 people found dead inside house in Minneapolis suburb of Coon Rapids after 911 call
- We Can Tell You How to Get to Sesame Street—and Even More Secrets About the Beloved Show
- Other passengers support man who opened emergency exit, walked on wing of plane in Mexico airport
- Maps, data show how near-term climate change could affect major port cities on America's East Coast
- 'Heartless crime': Bronze Jackie Robinson statue cut down, stolen from youth baseball field
- California teen pleads guilty in Florida to making hundreds of ‘swatting’ calls across the US
- Herbert Coward, who played Toothless Man in 'Deliverance,' killed in North Carolina crash
Ranking
- 'Heretic' spoilers! Hugh Grant spills on his horror villain's fears and fate
- 2 lucky New Yorkers win scratch-off games worth millions
- LSU vs. South Carolina highlights, score, stats: Gamecocks win after Angel Reese fouls out
- Harry Connick Sr., former New Orleans district attorney and singer's dad, dies at age 97
- Tuskegee University closes its campus to the public, fires security chief after shooting
- General Hospital Actor Tyler Christopher's Official Cause of Death Revealed
- Kenneth Eugene Smith executed by nitrogen hypoxia in Alabama, marking a first for the death penalty
- Mass graves are still being found, almost 30 years after Rwanda’s genocide, official says
Recommendation
-
Utah AD Mark Harlan fined $40,000 for ripping referees and the Big 12 after loss to BYU
-
Exotic animals including South American ostrich and giant African snail seized from suburban NY home
-
Relapse. Overdose. Saving lives: How a Detroit addict and mom of 3 is finding her purpose
-
Biden administration warned Iran before terror attack that killed over 80 in Kerman, U.S. officials say
-
Drone footage captures scope of damage, destruction from deadly Louisville explosion
-
Why Sharon Stone Says It's Stupid for People to Be Ashamed of Aging
-
Many Costa Ricans welcome court ruling that they don’t have to use their father’s surname first
-
Christina Hall Slams Load of S--t Rumor That She Refuses to Work With Women